Challenges of oligarchic rule in Georgia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31558/2519-2949.2025.1.4Keywords:
Oligarchic rule, informal governance, kleptocratic rule, offshore companies, European Commission report, constitutional institutions,Abstract
This article discusses the phenomenon of oligarchic rule; examines and analyzes the causes and characteristics of oligarchic governance in Georgia, the correlation between informal governance and kleptocratic rule, the rise of billionaire businessman Bidzina Ivanishvili, founder of Georgia's ruling party "Georgian Dream," within the country's power structure, as well as the stages and priorities of his subsequent activities. It also addresses the European Parliament's resolution and Transparency International's reports, which identify Bidzina Ivanishvili as the country's sole oligarch with a destructive role in Georgia's politics and economy, the European Commission's report on the "de-oligarchization law," and the response of the ruling party and Bidzina Ivanishvili to these recommendations. In modern Georgia, the main barriers to effective governance traditionally include elite corruption and "state capture." Moreover, while informal governance was previously considered mainly a domestic issue, since 2022, it has gained an international dimension. Georgia’s accession to the European Union now depends, among other factors, on overcoming oligarchic rule. Therefore, in the current political context, only the systematic and in-depth reforms based on the recommendations of the European Commission can facilitate the transformation of oligarchs into ordinary economic players, the "deoligarchization" of the state, and the stability of Georgia’s European course and uninterrupted progress in the EU integration process. The implementation of these processes will only be possible through the deep involvement of the international community and the protection of the Georgian people's votes and will in the 2024 parliamentary elections. At the same time, Georgia's illegitimate government is completely isolated from the free world. Its leaders are not invited to any European countries and cannot participate in any significant international meetings. Additionally, the process of sanctioning regime officials has already begun in certain countries. However, collective EU sanctions against them are being opposed by Hungary and Slovakia, as they traditionally stand against such measures.
References
European Parliament resolution of 9 June 2022 on violations of media freedom and the safety of journalists in Georgia (2022/2702(RSP)). URL:https://bit.ly/3SS9e0c. Viewed 31.10.24;
European Commission. (2022a.Opinion on Georgia's application for membership of the European Union. URL:https://neighbourhood-enlargement.ec.europa.eu/opinion-georgias-application- membership-europeanunion_en. Viewed 31.10.24;
GeorgiaToday. ge. (2022). MEP: ‘De-oligarchization’ Means ‘de-Bidzinization’ or ‘de-Ivanishvilization’ of Georgia. URL: https://georgiatoday.ge/mep-de-oligarchization-means-de-bidzinization-or-de-ivanishvilization-of-georgia/. Viewed 31.10.24;
Interpresnews.ge (2022a). Irakli Kobakhidze: Of course, there are oligarchs in Georgia: Kezerashvili, Saakashvili, Khazaradze and Japaridze - there are oligarchs there, there are no oligarchs here. URL: https://www.interpressnews.ge/ka/article/716313-irakli-kobaxize-ra-tkma-unda-sakartveloshi-oligarkebi-ariankezerashvili-saakashvili-xazaraze-da-japarize-oligarkebi-arian-ikit-aket-ar-aris-arcerti-oligarki/. Viewed 31.10.24;
Ipn Press Agency, (23.08.2022),The de-oligarchization of Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia: the EU condition for advancing the European perspective. Analysis by Dionis Cenuşa. URL: https://bit.ly/3rojb9S . Viewed 31.10.24;
Konończuk, W., Cenușa D., & Kakachia, K. (24.05.17), Oligarchs in Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia as key obstacles to reforms, Ion, M., (2021), "Taming the oligarchs? Democratization and state capture: the case of Moldova." Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 29;
Marandici, I., (2021), Taming the oligarchs? Democratization and State Capture: The Case of Moldova, Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization, Institute for European, Russian, and Eurasian Studies, The George Washington University, Volume 29, Number 1;
Pleines, H., (2016), Oligarchs and politics in Ukraine. Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 24, no.1, Yurchenko, Y., (2018). Ukraine and the empire of capital: From marketisation to armed conflict. Pluto Press;
Parliament of Georgia, (2022a), Parliament of Georgia. 2022b. Draft laws: "On de-oligarchization". URL: https://parliament.ge/legislation/24794. Viewed 31.10.24;
President of Ukraine.2021. President immediately signed the anti-oligarchic law passed by the Verkhovna Rada. URL: https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/prezident-nevidkladno-pidpisav-uhvalenij-verhovnoyu-radoyu-a-71445. Viewed 31.10.24;
Shelly, G., (2019), Contemporary Oligarchies in Developed Democracies. Springer;
Transparency International.org. (2021), CPI (2021), for Eastern Europe & Central Asia: democratic hopes in the shadow of growing authoritarianism. Available at: Link: URL: https://www.transparency.org/en/news/cpi-2021-eastern-europe-centralasia-democratic-hopes-growing-authoritarianism. Viewed 31.10.24;
Transparency International.org. (2019), From concentrated power to state capture: Georgia’s backsliding in the anti-corruption reforms. URL:https://www.transparency.org/en/blog/from-concentrated-power-to-state-capturegeorgias-backsliding-anti-corruption-reforms. Accessed 31.10.24;
JAM news, (24.06.2022) URL: https://bit.ly/3rqU7z5. Last checked 31.10.24;
Statement of NGOs on the possible abolition of the State Inspectorate Service, (26.12.21). URL:https://bit.ly/3SJQhNi. Accessed 31.10.24;
NGOs Assess the 2020 Parliamentary Elections, 04 November, (4.11.20). URL:https://bit.ly/3rorrGT. Accessed 31.10.24;
Gogolashvili K., (2024), Georgia is Changing Course - Where is it Heading? URL: https://gfsis.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/224-expert-opinion-geo.pdf. Accessed 23.08.24;
Zurabashvili, T., (2022), Deoligarchization in Georgia Against the Background of Oligarchs and Power Elites. GIP Policy Memorandum, Issue #64. URL:https://gip.ge/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/ფონიიკის-პელარარადული-64.pdf. Viewed 31.10.24;
Coalition for an Independent and Transparent Judiciary, A New Perspective of Judicial Reform, (21.06.21). URL: https://bit.ly/3CurEPl. Viewed 31.10.24;
Oligarch Ivanishvili – The Real Ruler of the Country and the Author of the Russian Foreign Policy, (29.05.24), URL: https://publika.ge/ti-oligarqi-ivanishvili-qveynis-realuri-mmartveli-da-rusuli-sagareo-kursis-avtori/. Viewed 31.10.24;
How should the recommendation of “deoligarchization” be implemented? The experiences of the “Associated Trio” on oligarchy and possible ways out. Center for Social Justice. URL: https://socialjustice.org.ge/uploads/products/pdf/ Деолигаркізизация_1668068720.pdf. Viewed 31.10.24;
Transparency International - Georgia, Is Georgia a Kidnapped State or Not, December 11, 2020.: URL: https://bit.ly/3dW1ETy. Viewed 31.10.24;
Social Justice Center Responds to Alleged Facts of Illegal Work of the State Security Service, (14.09.2021). URL: https://bit.ly/3CtqcfW. Verified 31.10.24;
Evaluation of the 2019 Spring Session, https://bit.ly/3rryi2o. Viewed 31.10.24;
Social Justice Center, Activism and the Exercise of the Right to Assembly - Analysis of Georgian Practice, Tbilisi, 2022 ; URL: https://bit.ly/3ydlyQN ; Viewed: 03.10.2022),
Transparency International - Georgia, Is Georgia a Hostage State or Not, (11.12.20). URL:https://bit.ly/3edydfM. Viewed 31.10.24.
აშშ-ის სახაზინო დეპარტამენტმა ბიძინა ივანიშვილს სანქციები დაუწესა | ყველა დეტალი ერთად URL: https://www.radiotavisupleba.ge/a/ivanishvili-sans-sanktsies-da-dautsedda/33254863.html. Viewed 31.10.24.
მაგნიტსკის სია - რას ნიშნავს აშშ-ის ეს სანქცია და ვინ ხვდება იქ? URL: https://bm.ge/news/magnitskis-sia-ras-nishnavs-ashsh-is-es-sanqtsia-da-vin-khvdeba-iq Viewed 31.10.24.